New York Makeup Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara, Very Black, 0.3 Fl Oz (Pack of 1) , K2466800

This is my very favorite waterproof mascara and for some reason it’s been impossible to find in stores now! Buyer beware of what seller you’re purchasing from when ordering on Amazon though. When I get it direct from Amazon or Maybelline it’s perfect. My last order came from a seller called ‘Online Minimarket’ and it’s dried out and unusable.

Love this mascara!!!!! BUT...IT IS DISCONTINUED!!!!!!! Can't find it in any stores except Amazon....but it costs $30!!!!!!!! And since it is discontinued, who knows how old it is sitting in the warehouse? Loved how I could swim in it all day, and then just wash it off with soap and water!

I curl my lashes and then I have to apply mascara and this is the only mascara which dries the quickest and it does not make my lashes fall straight. Perfect for folks who curl their lashes.

Does a nice job of lengthening and thickening my lashes - not too much effort needed. No racoon eyes, no flaking. Th eonly issue I has was the item I received was slightly goopy....perhaps fresher product would have been PERFECT & AMAZING.

I wish Mabelline wasn't discontinuing this, as it is literally the best mascara I've ever used (have been using for years). It keeps the curl in your lash after you apply it, holds through swimming and water sports, and then easily washes off with soap and water at night. Not needing to use makeup remover is so much easier on my lashes, and they have never been longer due to this mascara just using soap and water for removal. There is also no harsh chemical smell when you apply it. Maybelline, PLEASE CONTINUE TO MAKE THIS PRODUCT!!! Market it to outdoorsy women, as this is the only mascara me and my friends use, due to all the things above.

The best mascara! It is not the first time , I am buying this since 2018

Me encanta esta máscara!

I’ve researched for you... THIS IS YOUR WINNER! I have bought luxury brand, high-end mascara for 10 years, or more. My last tube was running low, and thinking as much as I spend for waterproof mascara, there may be better luxury brands, that are not as drying to my eyes that have been developed. Decided to research the best brands of waterproof mascara... I found inexpensive drugstore brands to $45 brands, that I could find highest review on. I bought 5 different brands to test, as based on lists made by beauty magazines. This one shined above the others for me, and it was among the very cheapest!! Win, Win! It showed more length in my lashes, even more than fiber-adding mascaras. It did not clump my lashes together like some brands. Finally, it did not make my eyelids feel dried out, and almost sore later in the day. I was willing to pay the higher prices I have for over a decade, but now I don’t have to. The only draw back MAY be that it may not last as long, but I have nothing to base that on yet. I did buy a second one, one for makeup bag and one in my purse/bag... buying both is still well UNDER the price of what I paid for one tube of my luxury brand. ...and it works so much better... Did you catch that? :) I use Neutrogena make up cleaning wipes, and it removes it well. This is your new favorite mascara!