Fictions

Personally, I loved this book. The product itself was of high quality, it arrived exactly as expected and on time. The stories in the book though, that's something else entirely. They are rich, and far more detailed than you could imagine for how short they are. The present amazing and thought provoking ideas wrapped up in a few pages. My personal favourite, 'The Garden Of Forking Paths', in incredible. It fills out the story perfectly initially, and you won't quite understand it (Or I didn't anyway) until the very last paragraph. There were other greats in there too, such as 'The Library Of Babel' and 'The Circular Ruins', but I have yet to read one that wasn't simply mindblowing.

The stories are superb - a dazzling parade staged by one of the few genuinely original writers of the last century. However, confusingly - perhaps in homage to Borges’s delight in the labyrinth? - the content of three Penguin Modern Classics, ‘Fictions’, ‘Labyrinths’ and ‘The Aleph’ overlap considerably. Almost all of ‘Fictions’ appears in ‘Labyrinths’, a volume that also includes selections from ‘The Aleph’. If you are going to buy one, ‘Labyrinths’ is probably the best bet. It also contains some of Borges’s non-fiction that is also covered in much greater depth in ‘The Total Library’.

Borges' collected fictions contains, not to put too fine a point on it, some of the most wonderful, magical stories ever written. The labyrinthine workings of his mind are reflected in his stories - quite literally in some places - and you will almost certainly want to visit Tlön, or his library - where you may get to read the infinite Book of Sand - the book of all books - or perhaps Herbet Quains trifurcating "April March". These stories have been the inspiration for so many authors over the years (and arguably for hypertext novels and "choose your own adventure" type books). Everybody should read them!

I'm afraid to say I lack the relationship to the author that others may have, and I feel that so much of how I enjoy books is based on my understand of the author and what they are trying to do. With Borges, although I recognise him as a giant of literature, especially given he hails from Argentina, I am not able, at the moment, to cross into fully appreciating what he has done or what he is doing. This being said, I enjoyed all of the worked in Fictions, and all of the short stories therein contained very brilliant writing, which I cannot deny made it hard no to desire to read more about Borges, and his further works. The humour and parody in 'Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote', and the detective fiction was the most engaging parts of the book for me, but throughout it contained many stories and ideas I had seen referenced but never read their source, like the Library of Babel. Now I have. The frequent references to time, paradox and others things rarely written in good fiction were brilliant, and as someone who knows and thinks there is a lot of awful mainstream fiction, this book was about as good as one could find, outside of my personal bias.

Amazing book. Best short story collection I've ever read. The book came undamaged.

Extremely clever, multi layered, hyper intellectual tome. Explores themes from religion and mysticism. Does not hit the spot for me. I much prefer the writings of Silvina Ocampo. I enjoyed the Carlos Castaneda flavoured The Circular Ruins though.

Excellent product and delivery very pleased

Whereas most writers regurgitate the same subjects of love or family, Borges finds his inspiration from philosophical concepts, and dazzles you with the stories he creates out of them.

For a literary neophyte like me, making an informed choice between “Ficciones / Fictions” and “The Aleph” as a Borges primer wasn’t easy. Thankfully, Penguin did make things simple with this omnibus edition that boasts of his collective body of fiction, all presented in a chronological sequence (shame they did away with the hardcover version though). Picking it up was thus, a no-brainer. It’s been three weeks since, and having savored five of the short story collections included (“A Universal History of Iniquity”, “Fictions”, “The Aleph”, “Brodie’s Report” and “the Book of Sand”), I find myself captivated by the Master’s style(s)! An eclectic mix of history, medieval philosophy, spirituality, magical realism, humor and mystery means the reader is always kept guessing about the author’s next move in tales that simultaneously amaze and tantalize with their unspoken allusions. Its foolhardy to try summarizing the entire expanse of this vast repertoire from a master storyteller. Better to take things up one collection at a time. Here are a few of his stories I simply adored in “Fictions” , the first four being included in “The Garden of Forking Paths”. 1. Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius : Borges at his imaginative best! The story revolves around a fictional country , Uqbar(and its conceptualization of a mythical realm, Tlön, like a dream within a dream) , that the Author ‘s friend stumbles upon in a certain forgotten edition of the Anglo-American Cyclopaedia. A bibliophile’s enthusiastic search for the origins of this mysterious land in forgotten bookshops and Libraries is what ensues That quest, however, ends in a dead trail. Years later, chance hands the author one of the many volumes of an obscure Encyclopedia devoted entirely to the mythical world of Tlön and authored by a secret organization , Orbis Tertius. What follows is a deep delve into a completely different world view (Empirical Idealism) that aligns with the Tlönian understanding of reality. A world where proper nouns are eschewed for impersonal verbs and where objects "grow vague or sketchy and lose detail" when they begin to be forgotten. 2. The Circular Ruins: A drifter painstakingly crafts his protégé within the mental realm in a dream world, with some assistance from a forgotten “Fire” God in the ruins of a jungle temple lost in time. An all-pervading mystical Gnosticism permeates the story and gives it an otherworldly aura. 3. The Library of Babel : Infinity and eternal time are a recurring theme in Borges’s works. This story takes it to dizzying heights, substituting the Universe for an eternally repeating motif of a Library of hexagonal galleries that is “unlimited, but periodic” and where supposedly exist works of invaluable importance (“The Vindications”) amidst a vast body of meaningless texts, a search for which has sent many a Librarian into the Void. This one’s heavy on symbolism, and in a way, reflects the true human existence, meaningless, futile, repetitive and with elusive hopes that often lead to disappointment. 4. The Garden of Forking Paths : A Chinese professor Yu Tsun, acting as a spy for Imperial Germany, is pursued by a British intelligence officer, and escapes into the country. Tsun ends up in the residence of a Sinologist, Dr. Stephen Albert (reason for which is revealed only in the end) who, incidentally ,is studying Tsun’s predecessor, Ts'ui Pen's incomplete labyrinthine novel that diverges into multiple forking paths representing the various possible futures that may spin out from each event. A brief metaphysical discussion on infinitely forking possible futures ensues, terminating in a dramatic culmination that has some serious wartime implications. 5. The Theme of the Traitor and the Hero (from “Artifices”) : A whodunit steeped in history and classical literature, the tale traces back the possible cause of the murder of Fergus Kilpatrick, an Irish revolutionary leader. Elaborating the storyline in detail would be a disservice of the spoiler kind to future readers. Suffice it to say that the narrator unravels the truth behind that incident with some help from “Julius Caeser”. Tagline? All the world’s a stage… , and that’s all the hint you will get out of me. 6. The Cult of the Phoenix (from “Artifices”): What is this secret Organization that has suffered persecutions (and has persecuted) through Eternity? A collective Body which lacks a single Holy text and scriptures, yet is bound by a Ritual that is sacred, yet “ridiculous”, “trivial” and “needs no description”? Borges mystifies and teases, finally leaving the fleshing out of the answer to the Reader, and it’s a piece that is bound to raise some interesting debates in the cha-adda table. 7. The Shape of the Sword (“Artifices” again) : Vengeance is best served hot. A usual revenge-themed tale that is turned upside down on its head once you realize who the protagonist actually is. The story is marred somewhat by the overexplaining at conclusion though. I’m sure someone like Maugham would have left the last paragraph out to keep some of the mystery intact. This heterogenous potpourri, however, represents only a handful of the gems that the compendium includes, mere drops in an ocean. Labyrinths, duels (of the mental and visceral kind), brushes with infinity and immortality, these are some of the recurrent motifs in his school of literature, a deep dive into which would require lengthy posts of their own. And then, there are those ethereal, hard to categorize works like “Averroës' Search” and “The Other” that inspire awe by their width of scope. Talking about them would require a detailed breakdown of works like “The Aleph”, “Brodie’s Report” and “The Book of Sand”.

I wanted to know what interested Curtis Yarvin about the story of Tlön. My curiosity was satisfied. Yarvin may have been looking for instructions on gray magic, on how to subtly manipulate ideological narratives without completely breaking with the prevailing order.

I think this is the best Borges collection, in my opinion.

J'ai commande deux livres de cet ecrivain comme cadeau pour mon fils pour son arriversaire. J'ai passe commande le jeudi et son anniversaire etait le dimanche. L'autre livre devait arriver le lendemain mais il n'est pas arrive ce jour la. Heureusement ce livre est arrive le samedi par la Poste et j'ai quelque chose a offrir a mon fils. Merci, la Poste! Quant au livre, c'est tout a fait ce que j'ai attendu.

I am listening to this in the Spanish language on Audible and following along at the same time with Andrew Hurley's paper back English translation. This paperback is very high quality in terms of its paper and its binding. It deserves a permanent place on bookshelves. I notice that Andrew Hurley's translation includes a short story "The Approach of Al-Mu'tasim" that is omitted from the Audible Spanish version. I think it's a good use of time to read every short story in this book, slowly, and at a rate of about one short story every two or three days. Jorge Luis Borges is very special, but he is not the easiest author to read. I think it's worth the effort. Andrew Hurley has done the world of English readers a great service by translating this book from Spanish. I hope one day someone will care enough to convert this paperback book into Kindle format.