Justin'sSuper Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups 6pk of 4.2oz bags Organic, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, Responsibly Source, Rainforest Alliance Certified CocoaUSDA OrganicRainforest AllianceRainforest AllianceRainforest AllianceRainforest Alliance

If you like dark chocolate and peanut butter you’ll like this item. Like the slight bitterness of the chocolate. Not as sweet as other brands of peanut butter cups.

These are my absolute favorite and I always buy these at Whole Foods. So when I saw they were on sale here, I bought a 6 pack. Well, they were very old tasting…the chocolate was almost faded around the edges. I checked the date and it was October 2025 but not sure when Amazon received them. It’s worth just spending the money and buying them fresh at Whole Foods or another store that sells them. I would share a picture but I already threw them out.

Much richer than the regular Justin’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups. Love that each one is individually wrapped. The only other place I have found these is Whole Foods where they are 6.99 per package. I am a dark-chocoholic and these are my new favorites. There is no chemical-type aftertaste, just smooth rich (slightly bitter - which is the 80%) dark chocolate peanut butter.

The peanut butter cups from Bena Group were poor quality. The chocolate had a white coat and the peanut butter was grey and chalky. The product was within best by date. Product is labeled to store below 65°F and keep away from heat and light. I believe it wasn't stored properly.

These Justin's Organic Super Dark Peanut Butter cups are hard to find. The photo shown (as of May 2023) shows their regular mini dark peanut butter cups which we can usually find in our local grocery stores. The Super Dark cups are bigger than the mini ones and so you only get 6 individually wrapped cups per bag. They are a little pricey but if you like very dark chocolate, these won't disappoint. Much like the regular dark chocolate cups, we've had varied qualities of chocolate and filling so beware that they are not always soft and creamy in the middle. The first batch I found online from the big W store were perfect but the second, not as good. Slightly more firm in the middle than normal but still tasty. I've since found them for a better price here on Amazon as well as much better packaging than from the big W. As their quality seems to be easily affected by either storage or exposure to heat and considering the high price of these chocolates, I'll give these 4 stars

Inconsistent. Sometimes these are wonderful. Great chocolate and creamy peanut butter. Sometimes the chocolate is covered in white film, and the filling is chalky and dry. It is not the shipping as this even happens with overnight shipping in cool weather. I love these so much when they don't have these problems.

Tasty great

This is one of my favorite snacks but this is the second time I’ve received a shipment of stale candies. The usually great peanut butter interior tastes powdery and the chocolate is crumbling. Cannot recommend buying from Amazon when the items have been sitting around for who knows how long.